Thesis may rejected in case when you totally fails to justify all your aims and objective, it is not possible. The PhD supervisor closely monitory your work. So thesis a rare case scenario but expert may advise revision or some minor to major changes in a PhD thesis and reappear in the viva again Oct 26, · Mar 05, · I’m one of the few PhD candidates in my department who is doing practice based thesis. I’ve made pieces for exhibition and written about them, which should be fun but, to be frank, it hasn’t been a pleasant Journey. I submitted my thesis 6 months ago and the result came back 4 weeks blogger.comted Reading Time: 8 mins
What does it feel like to have your PhD thesis/dissertation rejected? - Quora
Academia Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for academics and those enrolled in higher education. It only takes a minute to sign up. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I am planning to submit my thesis next month. I have 4 published SCI-indexed journals Elsevier, Springer, IEEE transaction, World Scientific and 2 more journals communicated all first authors. My phd dissertation rejected is on Bioinformatics and Computational Biology.
The thesis will be sent to two external examiners about whom I will not know Institute policy. I am fearing what will happen if my thesis somehow gets rejected I do not know why I am so scared right now. Kindly share any incident of thesis rejections if you know of any, why it was rejected and how the person finally got his phd dissertation rejected. This very much depends on which system you are in.
I can answer from the point of view of the UK system. Requirements for a thesis are generally set out by the university. They normally specify you must have made a "novel contribution to the field" and the work is, in principle, of publication quality. Or something similar. Slightly more in minor corrections probably. Very, very few fail outright. Four published journal articles and two under review, that sounds impressive to me! It's natural to fear your thesis will phd dissertation rejected rejected, it's natural to be scared: Search this forum for impostor syndrome.
Also, what happens when the thesis gets major revision? Do I have to do the corrections and send the thesis again? That'll likely depend on your institute and country. I suspect you'll need to make corrections in a timely fashion, perhaps your examiners will need to check they are satisfied. A novel valid contribution to your field just like a journal articlemastery of the material, and a broad understand of your domain.
From what you've posted, this is far from your situation. So, while occasion anxiety is understandable, it is probably unwarranted in your case. I also know of one case where someone's PhD was found to highly overlap with another PhD in another area with completely different terminology. Math vs CS That was awful for everyone involved - in that case they were given more time by the committee to come back and address it, and eventually they graduated.
Although probably technically illegal, it is also probable that any sensible examiner would quietly contact your supervisor before submitting a report if there was a major problem with the thesis, phd dissertation rejected, if only to make sure there was no major misunderstanding and avoid embarrassment for phd dissertation rejected student but also for those like the thesis director who allowed the thesis to go forward.
My experience is that examiners will prefer to hold their noses and accept a marginal or bad thesis rather than cause trouble and reject the submission. The most likely outcome is that you will phd dissertation rejected asked to make minor revisions, and then your school will have some procedure to handle this time-wise. Usually the examiners do not need to see the thesis again when resubmitted after minor corrections.
You want the examiner to engage with and improve the outcome to raise the visibility of the results. In 35 or so years of experience, I know for certain of only three cases where a thesis was rejected: in two instances a document was submitted over the objection of the thesis director; in the third instance a real error was found in the thesis. Since this is exceptionally rare, you tend to hear about such instances when they happen.
Thankfully, I was not involved directly in any of the situations. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, phd dissertation rejected. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Phd dissertation rejected more. When can a thesis get rejected or asked for a major revision?
Ask Question. Asked 11 months ago. Active 11 months ago. Viewed 2k times. Should I be worried that my thesis may get rejected? When a reviewer is checking a thesis, usually what does he want in it? Does he read the entire thesis line by line? phd thesis peer-review thesis-committee bioinformatics. Improve this question. asked Aug 19 '20 at girl girl 2, 2 2 gold badges 14 14 silver badges 25 25 bronze badges. Surely you have been a PhD student long enough to have asked other students what they went through?
Have you asked your supervisor? With several journal publications in solid or better journals, it's very unlikely to be rejected. If the supervisor gave you green light, they assume you are fine, phd dissertation rejected. It is good to be anxious to some extent, but at this stage, according to what you report, it does not look like an existential matter.
Of course, we do not know the details of the case, but I do not see red flags here. where are you? Thesis submission and marking processes vary wildly between different academic cultures. I have never heard of a Phd dissertation rejected thesis being rejected. It would reflect catastrophically on the advisor and damage the relationship between the advisor and other examiners. Usually, phd dissertation rejected, submission of the thesis needs approval by the advisor.
You can trust your advisor to recognize if a thesis is such utter trash that it can be rejected, phd dissertation rejected. This is a question you should be asking to your advisor and committee. It is not a question for strangers on the internet. Show 4 more comments. Active Oldest Votes. It is very un likely your thesis will be outright rejected. It is very likely you will be asked to make some corrections.
Yes, you will have to make the corrections and send the thesis again. Yes, phd dissertation rejected, a good examiner will read the thesis line by line. There are five possible outcomes from the examination of a thesis. Accepted without corrections Minor corrections - generally textual changes only - 3 month time limit Major corrections - might involve some reanalysis, but no new experiments - 6 month time limit.
Resubmit - this thesis does not pass, but contains sufficient material to convince the examiners you are capable of passing. You are giving leave to rewrite and resubmit the thesis. May involve new experiments - often 1 year time limit. Fail either with or without a Master of Philosophy degree. Improve this answer. answered Aug 19 '20 at Ian Sudbery Ian Sudbery 26k 2 2 phd dissertation rejected badges 64 64 silver badges 86 86 bronze badges.
I'm in the UK system as well. I've been supervisor and examiner and I've seen what happened to other students. From my experience 1. I have made this decision as examiner, phd dissertation rejected, and had it made by other examiners for one of my students although that was apparently not based on the thesis in the first place, phd dissertation rejected, more on viva performance ; I have examined less phd dissertation rejected 10 and supervised I've also seen this happening in other cases.
I agree with the rest, by and large. Disciplinary differences I guess - I've never done it, nor had it done to one of my students. Of my colleagues, I only know of one or two occasions where they have given out a re-submission. This would match my US experience in biology. I would say the number for anything worse than "major corrections" is effectively zero when the advisor supports the thesisphd dissertation rejected, and phd dissertation rejected or 5 become much more likely if not.
Most who would otherwise fall into 4 or especially 5 would likely not even submit a thesis. Add a comment. It's natural to fear your thesis will get rejected, it's natural to be scared: Search this forum for impostor syndrome Also, what happens when the thesis gets major revision?
That depends on the examiner. user user The other answers have generally good advice, to address a specific question you had: Kindly share any incident of thesis rejections if you know of any, phd dissertation rejected it was rejected and how the person finally got his degree.
I only know of one thesis that was completely rejected. In this case: The student had a very weak publication record, phd dissertation rejected.
What Happens When You Leave the Room After Your Dissertation Defense?
, time: 3:19phd - When can a thesis get rejected or asked for a major revision? - Academia Stack Exchange
Thesis may rejected in case when you totally fails to justify all your aims and objective, it is not possible. The PhD supervisor closely monitory your work. So thesis a rare case scenario but expert may advise revision or some minor to major changes in a PhD thesis and reappear in the viva again Aug 18, · I have never heard of a PhD thesis being rejected. It would reflect catastrophically on the advisor and damage the relationship between the advisor and other examiners. Usually, submission of the thesis needs approval by the advisor. You can trust your advisor to recognize if a thesis is such utter trash that it can be rejected Oct 26, ·
No comments:
Post a Comment